Cow's milk vs formula

K

kashismum

Registered User
I'm sure a definitive answer doesn't exist, but I'm interested in others' opinions.

Both my children were breastfed for the first year. After that, I introduced cow's milk slowly. I'm now doing that with my son who just turned a year, but my husband is convinced that formula has other 'good stuff' in it that cow's milk doesn't.

I prefer the idea of cow's milk as it is a more natural substance, but I also worry about the hormones and all the bad stuff you hear.

Also, neither of my children eat fish as I am allergic, and I hear that some fatty acids/oil only occuring in fish are added to formula.

I'm confused. My tendency is to stick with cow's milk unless anyone has a compelling argument to the contrary.

Thanks
 
Formula vs Cows milk

To give you a quick answer, your husband is right.

Infant formula is formulated from cows milk (dried out like skim milk powder) and added with many different minerals and vitamins a baby needs during its first year of life. Regular cows milk only has a few minerals and is usually fortified with Vit D as well. We generally switch to cows milk at a year of age as the child is getting all the vitamins and minerals he/she needs from other foods. So if your child is a good eater, they don't necessarily need to remain on formula.

As for the oils in fish, I think what your husband is talking about are long chain fatty acids from both omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids. A few years back Formula Companies started adding these long chain fatty acids called DHA and AA, These fatty acids are important for brain development. Research over the years found that these long chain fatty acids in breastmilk and decided to add them to the formula. These long chain fatty acids are generally made in the body from shorter fatty acids called linoleic and linolenic fatty acids. There is still research being done on whether infants produce their own (and if they do how much) DHA and AA from these precursors.

These precursors and the long chain fatty acids can be found in the "good oils" like olive and canola oils. They are also found in fish and fish oils, avacodos, omega eggs, and many nuts and seeds to name a few.

So if your child eats a variety of foods, I would say stick with cows milk. Just make sure it is homogenized (3.25% milk fat) and pasturized! I say pasturized because I found some milk being sold in the Park N Shop that was unpasturized!!!

Hope this helps.

Denise Fair, MSc, RD
 
Last edited:
we kept giving our son formula until he was 2 (will do the same for our daughter) as it was cheaper...for us, that was the deciding factor.
 
My son was breastfed for ten months, then had follow on milk for two months, and then at 12 mnths we started with cow's milk.

My son didn't like the follow on milk at all, and it was difficult to get him to drink it. The cow's milk however he loved!
I would rather give cow's milk...again because of the whole natural argument, versus something that is, in essence, a man made product!
 
Interesting question. I personally would just introduce fresh cow's milk. There's no need in making the transition to formula, and then transitioning again to fresh milk. That's twice the work to me. Yes, formula does have lots of vitamins, and minerals, and other stuff added to it, but they are all manmade!! Your son can be getting these nutrients from real foods instead. And if you continue to breastfeed, even better!

If you are allergic to fish, it is not the DHA and ARA that's giving you the allergic reaction...it's the proteins in the fish that's making you react to it. (Besides, the DHA and ARA in formula are man-made/synthetic..not taken from the fish). So I think you don't have to worry about that part.

So my opinion is to stick with cow's milk, especially since you are already doing this.
 
It seems to me, and I may be wrong that the formula vs cow's milk debate for toddlers is a cultural thing....

I don't know, but it seems common in Asia to give formula to toddlers, whereas in Europe/Western countries it is more common to give cow's milk.

I don't know if this has anything to do with the prevalence of milk and dairy products in Western food, and their absence in Asian food....!

I know fresh cow's milk isn't always particularly easy to get hold of in some Asian countries, nor is it particularly cheap. Whereas in western countries it's considered a staple/necessity and is very cheap.

Just wondered what other's thought, had found!
 
Milk and Dairy products are very much present in Indian food. In India all Doctors recommend switching to Cows Milk once the child turns 1. So it is a personal choice
 
I agree with Bekyboo. If you are in a household that drinks a lot of cow’s milk then you are likely to always have it around and so it is natural to give the baby this milk as he reaches 12 months. If, however, you are in a household that rarely buys cow’s milk you are much more likely to continue giving formula. Cow’s milk tends to go off quickly so unless the whole family is using it there could be a lot of wastage.
 
bekyboo is correct also. Formula beyone 1 year old is very common in Asian countries, whereas it is less common in Western places. Maybe it also has to do with Asian's dislike of cow's milk and dairy products??
 
I'm Chinese and I don't drink milk except when I'm pregnant or with my coffee / tea which I only drink at home at weekends. My husband (also Chinese) doesn't drink milk at all. Therefore, sometimes the 1L carton of milk we buy gets thrown out before it's finished as it's already turned sour. Most Chinese I know hardly drink any milk or even coffee/tea at home. So it's not really that pravalent in our diets, hence that's probably why formula is more popular with the toddlers.
 
We had the problem of milk going off at home too. So I changed to buying six packets of small cartons (only 250 mls each). This costs more than buying the large cartoons (1 litre) but I decided as the small carton doesn?t go off as much I was in fact winning.
 
it depends on what you mean by "asia". atleast in southeast asia milk is an important part of diet for all ages and consumed in good quantities.
 
To throw another side to the argument, I recently took my daughter to the Peadiatrician who asked me if my daughter was on formula or cows milk (she is now 16 months). When I advised cows milk she said this was good as formula was not great for their teeth. Not sure if this is true or not.
Another thing to consider is how much travel you do. We switched to cows milk once my daughter was 12 months old. We have done a lot of travel and often been caught out in flight and in hotels who are unable to provide adequate cows milk. We would not have had this problem if we could take formula and just mix with water in flight or in a hotel room.
In saying this though, we do prefer cows milk, it is easy, convenient to obtain (when at home), no measuring or mixing and not fussed when there is wasteage (it is cheaper than forumla). Good luck, but if you are not fussed about the other factors, I would stick with cows milk as opposed to doing two transitions.
 
cow's milk cheaper than formula? not for us!
a litre of cow's milk is $20+ it would last us less than a day.... that would be $600+ per month. we spend $250-300/month on formula, but my daughter drinks A LOT of "milk"
 
later stages of formula taste sweet so must have added sugar in. my daughter didn't like it either and liked fresh milk. guess that's why some paeds say it's bad for teeth...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top